Nolan's On Canandaigua Lake

We just had an amazing dinner at Nolan's this evening, everything was perfect, my daughter and I loved our Chicken French, it was great! For a drink I usually have wine but felt like having something a little different so I asked for an Italian martini. It wasn't on the menu but the waitress took the time to find out from me what goes into making one and she had the bartender make it for me! It was so good and refreshing, I really enjoyed it along with my meal and visiting with family in this beautiful restaurant with excellent service and ambiance. Thank you!

Had a business meeting in Newark and our hotel was on Lake Canadagua. Decided to try this place out on the first night. Note: word of warning, the menu prices online did not match the menu prices at the restaurant. It was much more expensive at the restaurant. Service was good. Very down to earth and our waitress checked on us regularly. Nice lady. It is a bit pricey: Ordered the following items Seafood chowder and 12 oz Prime Rib with a Coca Cola. Total adds up to $58.32 plus 11 dollar tip $69.32 for one. Kinda pricey. Quality of food: I have to say that the seafood chowder was absolutely amazing. It was cooked to perfection. And, you can tell, it was cooked from scratch. Likewise, I cannot complain about the Prime Rib. It was excellent. I would definitely recommend dining here (bit pricey), but the quality and service is very good.

Came here with some family and friends, always make reservations ... it gets busy. We arrived and there was a lot of people waiting, however we bypassed all of them. Seated on their back dining room with a cozy fire place. Server came right over to let us know the specials and get our drink order. I went with a big ditch hay burner on draft. There's a tv monitor that shows photos and tells you again what the specials and most popular items are. I went with the captain Pete fish and chips, delicious. Fresh North Atlantic beer battered cod with fries and coleslaw. So much food. A few people got steak. Captains platter was very popular too. 8oz filet 6oz lobster tail and shrimp. Everything was great.

My husband and I made a reservation for dinner tonight to celebrate our 44th wedding anniversary, and as always, we were not let down. The food, service, and atmosphere were outstanding. Our waiter, Marshall, was excellent, and we even had the pleasure of meeting one of the owners, Nick, as he went around to check on his guests. Every time we eat here, we are impressed. If you find yourself in the Finger Lakes region, especially during the busy summer months, be sure to make a reservation. You will not be disappointed. We are grateful to have such a wonderful dining option in Canandaigua.

Nolan's is a lovely restaurant located by Canandaigua Lake. We ordered mashed potatoes and steamed broccoli for our almost one-year-old baby, lobster ravioli, and fish and chips. The baby enjoyed his meal and mom agreed. The lobster ravioli was fantastic, with a phenomenal taste and generous portions of lobster. It was worth the price. However, the fish and chips were lacking in flavor and not very special. The service was a bit inconsistent, with our server being friendly but a bit overwhelmed. Overall, it was a positive experience and we would recommend this restaurant to others.