Mary Jane's Dairy - Newburgh

There was something wrong with the freak shake. It had an awful taste to it. When I talked to the manager she slung it in the garbage and said she has milk shakes all day long and there wasn’t anything wrong with it. She gave a replacement cup of ice cream and gave me the difference in cash. She certainly needs to work on her people skills. Been coming here since I was a kid but won’t be back unfortunately since although the ice cream that I ended up with was good the manager totally turned me off to returning. Sad

Meal type: Other Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5

I recently visited Mary Jane's Dairy Bar, and I have to say, the customer service was outstanding! From the moment I arrived, the staff was friendly and welcoming. They truly went above and beyond. The manager also took the time to personally greet us, which made the visit feel even more special. You can tell she deeply cares about the customers. Now, let's talk about the freak shakes! These iconic creations are not only a visual treat but a true delicacy. You won't be disappointed. Every sip was pure euphoria! If you're looking for a place that combines excellent customer service with some of the best freak shakes you'll ever taste, this is the spot. I can’t wait to go back!

Meal type: Other Price per person: $1–10 Food: 5 Service: 5 Atmosphere: 5

I have been coming to Mary Janes for years and I have never had a bad experience. The employees are well trained and knowledgeable. The owner does an amazing job at keeping her customers happy like myself. Never disappointed!! So happy to have them reopened. Mary Janes has a small town feel brings the community together with the best ice cream around. Food: 5