Carbone's Pizzeria - Rochester

The pizza is delicious, but the wings are often not cooked well and end up soggy unless specifically asked to be fried crispy.

This is the best pizza I've ever had. You don't even need to ask for extra cheese or toppings - it's already perfect. I was willing to drive all the way from West Henrietta just to have their pizza.

Carbone's used to be known as the best, but my experience tonight was not good. I ordered a pizza and 10 wings, they said it would be ready in 30 minutes. I arrived 5 minutes early and saw that my pizza was done and sitting there, but I had to wait 15 more minutes for my wings. I told the teenager that my pizza was ready 15 minutes earlier and she just said you're welcome and walked away. When I got home, my wings were hot and great, but my pizza was lukewarm and the cheese was dried up. It's sad to see that the quality has changed so much from when John and Tom Carbone were in charge 30 years ago. It's disappointing how times have changed.

I love the place, especially the location dewey ave. wings are best in rustester: leaf 50 wings for 75$, while each other place 40$ as jeremias for 20 wings. you will not be disappointed with carbones

Excellent pizza. Usually pretty busy, but never waited more than 45 mins after ordering. Next step would be to support an online ordering platform.