Pizza By The Square - Bluewater

While we found the prices to be a bit higher than chain restaurants, the quality of the pizza and the generous toppings more than justified the cost. In my opinion, it truly is the best pizza around. We ordered two family-sized pizzas for five people (mostly hungry boys!), and we ended up with an entire pizza left over—they were so filling! You absolutely have to try this hidden gem!

I absolutely loved this restaurant! The pizza was delicious. I ordered two different pizzas, and they offered a great variety. The Hot Diggity Dog pizza is perfect for kids! This place is definitely my top choice!

Loved it !! We spent a week in Bayfield and decided to grab a pizza for an easy dinner. It was perfect, we ordered the Mainstreet and I especially loved the crust, thin and crispy how we like it. Reheated the rest the next day for lunch in the oven and came out just as good. Support the local businesses, this ones a keeper !!!

This is the best pizza my husband and I have ever had! The guy who took our order at the counter was incredibly friendly. Thank you, Pizza by the Square—you’re awesome!

Great pizza very friendly service , the best pizza around !!